Does pine tar soap actually work?

I've heard that pine tar soap is great for acne. (even better than proactive) If you have tried it .. can you please tell me if it actually works. Also .. is it true you need a prescription to get it?

Does pine tar soap actually work?
Well, I've never used it, but I did a search and came across this thread with people talking about the results they got:


http://www.acne.org/messageboard/index.p...





It seems really interesting, I'm going to look into buying some myself! The brand that keeps coming up (the thread, Amazon and in internet searches) is Grandpa's Pine Tar Soap. Search it and see where it might sell near you, or buy some online.
Reply:There doesn't seem to be anything other than anecdotal evidence that pine tar is effective for acne, and it was banned from use in dandruff products by the FDA in 1990. I would recommend sticking with products that actually have clinical evidence to support their effectiveness: salicylic acid, benzoyl peroxide, sulfur. If over-the-counter preparations are not effective for you, it's time to see a dermatologist for more aggressive treatments.
Reply:I've used it and it works for me! I think it's great. I used Grandpa's Wonder soap. I really like the smell - but I guess a lot of people won't. I'd happily recommend it - it doesn't cost much and if it works for you then it'll be worth it - and if it doesn't then you won't have wasted much money.





And you don't need a prescription - you do need a prescription for real coal tar though. Coal tar soaps that you can buy in the shops don't actually contain coal tar any longer. Fortunately pine tar doesn't need a prescription.
Reply:I've only seen in sold (I believe) In Health-food


stores but have never heard of it working on acne,


sorry.


Proactiv produces mixed results. Depending on your


kind of acne, severity, etc. you may want to use a


good face wash, and stay away from greasy foods,


- Trust me - also Coca Cola...





But - If you're looking for a more advanced remedy,


I'd recommend going to see a dermatologist...


Clinique Acne Solutions system did get me through


a bad case of acne in my teens and twenties, though!
Reply:I've seen it in health food stores. I don't know if it works on acne.
Reply:Ive heard of that to but never tried it. You dont need a prescription you can probably find it at wal-mart it is rather inexpensive.